Two approaches
In module-level repair, the complete defective unit (a board, a power supply, a drive) is removed and another is fitted. In component-level repair, the diagnosis is made inside the unit and only the damaged part is replaced, such as a capacitor, a semiconductor or a connector.
Comparison
| Criterion | Module | Component |
|---|---|---|
| Downtime | Short if a spare is available | May be longer |
| Skill required | Lower | Higher: diagnosis and soldering |
| Cost of the part | High on complex equipment | Low if the defect is located |
| Availability | Depends on the manufacturer | An advantage if the module is discontinued |
| Information about the cause | Little if the module is not analyzed | High |
Decision criteria
- Cost of downtime: if every hour stopped is expensive, change the module and repair it later offline.
- Availability of spares: a discontinued module or one with a long lead time favors component repair.
- Complexity: boards with very fine surface-mount components or special packages may require specific equipment.
- Documentation: without schematics, component repair relies more on comparison with a healthy board.
- Safety and warranty requirements: on some equipment, user intervention may be restricted.
A criterion that gets forgotten
Repairing only the component without finding out why it failed can lead to recurrence. A burned-out semiconductor usually has a cause in its drive or in the load. Even if you choose to change the module, it is advisable to analyze the one removed to learn the cause.
How to verify
After any repair, the assembly is tested under load and under the conditions that caused the failure. If the equipment involves power or hazardous voltage, the work must be carried out by qualified personnel in accordance with applicable regulations.