How they produce torque
In the permanent magnet synchronous motor, the rotor carries magnets that create their own field; the stator creates a rotating field and the rotor follows it in synchronism. In the induction motor, the rotor is a conductive cage without magnets; the stator field induces currents in it and torque arises from that interaction, with a slip between the field speed and the rotor speed.
Differences that matter
- Efficiency: the magnet motor needs no current to magnetize the rotor and has no losses from rotor currents, so it tends to be more efficient, especially at partial load.
- Power density: the magnet motor delivers more torque in a smaller size.
- Materials: high-performance magnets use rare earths, with a dependence on specific supply chains. The induction motor avoids that material.
- High-speed operation: both require field weakening; in the magnet motor, this is achieved by injecting current that reduces the flux, which adds losses.
The safety difference
A spinning magnet motor generates voltage in its windings even when the inverter is off. If the vehicle is towed or coasts at high speed, that voltage can exceed the bus voltage and requires protection strategies in the inverter. The induction motor, without excitation, generates no voltage when spinning. In addition, the magnet motor carries a small no-load spinning loss, and the magnets can demagnetize with excessive temperature or too high a current.
What is seen on a test bench
When the efficiency map is measured, the magnet motor shows a wider high-efficiency zone; the induction motor maintains a good response at high speed and more tolerant behavior under overloads. Control of the induction motor requires estimating the rotor flux, while the magnet motor needs to know the rotor position precisely.
The choice is a balance of cost, efficiency, supply and control strategy. Work on the traction system is for qualified personnel.