The padlock does hold; it is the system that fails
A padlock performs its mechanical function of preventing a device from being operated. Incidents that happen with a lockout in place are usually because the lockout did not cover the whole hazard or was not verified.
Frequent failures
- Unidentified source: the equipment had a second supply, a control circuit fed from another source, or backfeed from a generator, a UPS or a neighboring installation.
- Wrong lockout point: the start control or the breaker of a similar piece of equipment was locked, not the isolating device.
- Residual energy: charged capacitors, trapped pressure, compressed springs, parts raised against gravity, or heat still present.
- Lack of verification: nobody checked that the equipment would not start or that voltage was absent.
- A single padlock for several people: someone removes it believing everyone has finished.
- Improper removal: someone else’s padlock is taken off, a duplicate key is used, or the lock is cut without following the corresponding procedure.
- Poorly communicated shift change: the incoming crew does not know what is locked out or why.
- Unsuitable devices: padlocks or accessories that do not close properly on the handle, so the switch can still move.
Why it happens
These are system errors. The plant does not keep its diagrams up to date, isolation points are not identified, the procedure is generic, there is a rush to restart, or the safety culture does not penalize shortcuts. A lockout that “has always worked” may have worked by chance.
What to check first
- That the procedure is written for that equipment, with all its isolation points.
- That each worker has their own padlock and key.
- That the zero energy state is verified before touching anything.
- That there is a method for transfer between shifts.
- That lockouts are audited in the field.
These activities must be carried out by qualified personnel, following the applicable regulations.