Two different objectives
A handheld vibration meter asks whether overall vibration has increased. A full analyzer answers where it comes from and what is causing it. They are tools with complementary purposes, not better and worse versions of the same thing.
What the vibration meter provides
- An overall value, generally in velocity, sometimes with acceleration and temperature.
- An immediate reading, with no frequency analysis.
- Ease of use for operations and maintenance personnel.
With it you can detect that something has changed, compare similar machines and monitor a trend. An overall level can hide a significant defect in a narrow band while the total stays low, because a strong component at one frequency can be diluted in the sum.
What the analyzer adds
- FFT spectrum to separate components and link them to a cause: unbalance, misalignment, looseness, bearings, gears.
- Waveform and phase.
- Averaging, windowing and demodulation functions.
- Memory and routes, in the case of data collectors.
How to choose
- If it is enough to know whether the machine is within its normal level, the vibration meter is an efficient tool.
- If the level has risen and the cause is needed, an analyzer is required.
- If diagnosis will be routine, training in spectral interpretation is required.
When it does not apply
An instrument without the training to interpret its data produces numbers without decisions. A simple instrument used well is preferable to a complex one misinterpreted.
An example
An operator walks through an area with a vibration meter and notices that one fan reads higher than its twins. That is enough to open an inspection work order. An analyst then connects an analyzer, sees a peak at one times running speed and diagnoses unbalance. The first instrument detected the deviation; the second identified the cause.