Two different objectives
In the qualitative approach the question is “what looks different?” You look for areas that contrast with their surroundings or with identical equipment, and the exact number matters less. In the quantitative approach the question is “what temperature is it?”, because the decision depends on a value: comparing it with a material limit, a reference, or a previous measurement.
What each approach requires
- Qualitative: good focus, level and range suited to the contrast, and similar load conditions across the parts being compared. It tolerates an approximate emissivity, because similar surfaces are being compared.
- Quantitative: correct emissivity for the material, reflected apparent temperature, distance, humidity and ambient temperature, a target that fills several pixels, and a camera with a current calibration.
What the engineer sees
Three terminals on adjacent phases under the same load: one looks hotter. That is already a useful qualitative result, because comparing like with like cancels much of the emissivity error. But if you need to know whether a bearing has exceeded the maximum temperature of its lubricant, that comparative finding is not enough and you must measure rigorously.
How to choose
| Situation | Approach |
|---|---|
| Detecting an anomalous component among several identical ones | Qualitative, with comparison |
| Verifying a temperature limit | Quantitative |
| Tracking a point over time | Quantitative, under the same conditions |
| Quick reconnaissance inspection | Qualitative |
Common errors
- Reporting as an absolute value a temperature obtained without adjusting emissivity.
- Comparing inspections from different days without recording load and ambient conditions.
- Dismissing a clear qualitative finding for lack of a “precise” number.
- Taking a surface temperature as the internal temperature of the component.