What the substrate changes in the antenna
In a patch or printed-line antenna, the resonant dimensions scale with the wavelength inside the substrate. A higher permittivity shortens that wavelength and reduces the size of the antenna. But the field becomes more confined in the substrate, which lowers the bandwidth and usually lowers the radiation efficiency.
The main trade-off
- Low permittivity: wider bandwidth and good efficiency, larger antenna.
- High permittivity: compact antenna, with narrower bandwidth and greater sensitivity to tolerances.
- Thickness: a thicker substrate increases bandwidth and radiation, but favors surface waves that reduce efficiency.
Losses
The loss tangent of the dielectric and the conductor losses reduce efficiency. At microwave and millimeter-wave frequencies this choice is critical, so low-loss laminates are used. Copper roughness adds further losses.
Stability and tolerances
- The actual permittivity differs from the nominal value within a certain tolerance, and since the resonant frequency depends on it, the antenna can shift.
- Permittivity varies with temperature, the substrate absorbs moisture, and the frequency drifts.
- The anisotropy of reinforced laminates affects polarization and resonance.
Other criteria
- Copper thickness and etching quality at the patch edge.
- Compatibility with the fabrication and assembly process.
- Mechanical stiffness, and conformability if the antenna must be curved.
- Cost relative to the required performance.
How to verify
Measure the permittivity and losses of the actual substrate at the design frequency, simulate with those data and validate with a prototype. A frequency shift between simulation and measurement usually points to the actual permittivity or to thickness tolerances.