24/7 emergencies 814 777 6921812 230 6079WhatsApp 811 786 0768
Electrónica MonterreyElectrónica MonterreyLaboratorios Creativeit Talk to an engineer
Menu

Why a leak test gives inconsistent results

A leak test is inconsistent almost always because what changes is not the leak, but the temperature, the volume or the equilibrium of the system. A real loss has to be separated from a thermal or instrumentation effect.

The most frequent cause: temperature

In a closed vessel containing gas, the pressure rises and falls with temperature. When pressurizing with a gas, compression heats it; as it cools toward ambient temperature, the pressure drops even if there is no leak. That drop can be mistaken for a real loss or, conversely, a small leak can be masked by warming of the surroundings.

Other sources of inconsistency

  • Insufficient stabilization time: the system is still settling thermally and mechanically when the measurement begins.
  • System volume: with a large volume, a small leak produces a small pressure change; with a small volume, the same orifice is more noticeable.
  • Instrument: limited resolution, transmitter drift or a gauge that cannot distinguish the change being sought.
  • Leaks in the instrumentation itself: connections, hoses, test valves and plug seals.
  • Seating of seals and gaskets: they settle over time, and the leak changes between repetitions.
  • Test fluid: a nearly incompressible liquid behaves differently from a gas, and air trapped in a hydrostatic test mimics a leak.

What it looks like in practice

Two repetitions of the same procedure give different drops; the test passes in the morning and fails in the afternoon; the result changes with shade or sun on the equipment. If the drop decreases over time until it stabilizes, it is usually thermal; if it remains constant, a real leak is more likely.

How to reduce the variability

  • Allow the temperature to stabilize and record it together with the pressure.
  • Use a duration and an acceptance criterion defined in advance.
  • First verify that the test setup itself does not leak, by isolating it with a blind plug.
  • Use a method suited to the size of the leak: pressure decay, bubble testing, tracer gas detection or flow.
  • Correct or compensate for temperature whenever possible.

For equipment that contains pressure, the test must be performed by qualified personnel following the applicable procedures and codes.

We do real tests, on video! Watch them on our YouTube channel →

Do you have a problem nobody has been able to measure?

Talk directly to the engineer in charge, with no middlemen.

Talk to an engineer