Two ways of reading the same diaphragm
Both principles measure the deformation of a diaphragm subjected to pressure. What changes is how that deformation is converted into an electrical signal, and their strengths derive from that.
Piezoresistive
Gauges whose resistance changes when deformed are diffused or deposited on the diaphragm, which is normally silicon. They are connected in a Wheatstone bridge, and its imbalance is the signal. The sensor is made with microelectronics techniques, which lowers the cost of volume production.
- Covers a wide range of pressures, including high ones.
- Fast response.
- The signal depends on temperature, so it requires compensation.
Capacitive
The diaphragm is one plate of a capacitor and, as it deforms, the distance to a fixed plate changes and, with it, the capacitance. The electronics convert that variation into a signal.
- Very good sensitivity in low pressure ranges.
- Suitable for low-value differential measurements and for zero stability.
- Requires nearby electronics, and is sensitive to stray capacitance and to moisture in the sensor.
Comparison
| Aspect | Piezoresistive | Capacitive |
|---|---|---|
| Principle | Change in gauge resistance | Change in capacitance |
| Typical range | Wide, toward high pressures | Stands out at low and differential pressures |
| Temperature effect | Significant, compensated | Generally smaller, also compensated |
| Overpressure | Depends on the design | Depends on the design; some diaphragms rest against a support |
| Electronics | Simple | More elaborate |
How to choose
- Define the range and the type of pressure: gauge, absolute or differential.
- For high pressures or general, rugged applications, the piezoresistive principle is usually the starting point.
- For low pressures or small differentials, and when zero stability matters, consider the capacitive principle.
- Check the behavior under overpressure, temperature and the fluid: certain designs need isolation or a diaphragm seal.
When this rule does not apply
The differences depend largely on the design and the manufacturer: a well-compensated sensor of one principle can outperform a poorly executed sensor of the other. For that reason, the data sheet with stability, temperature effect and overpressure is more decisive than the principle alone.