Neither is better in general
The right question is not which sensor is better, but which one meets the demands of the process. Each solves different problems well.
Comparison
| Criterion | RTD | Thermocouple |
|---|---|---|
| Principle | Variation in the resistance of a metal, usually platinum | Voltage from the Seebeck effect between two metals |
| Accuracy and repeatability | Generally better | Generally lower |
| Long-term stability | Good | Can drift, especially at high temperature |
| Range | More limited toward high temperatures | Very wide, up to very high temperatures |
| Response | Usually slower, depending on construction | Can be very fast with fine wire |
| Ruggedness against vibration and shock | More delicate | More rugged |
| Signal | Larger, measured as resistance | Very small, sensitive to noise |
| Compensation | Compensate for lead resistance | Compensate for the reference junction |
| Cost of the assembly | Sensor generally more expensive | Inexpensive sensor, with special cable |
How to decide
- Define the range. If the process exceeds what an RTD can withstand, the thermocouple is the option.
- Define the accuracy needed. For tight tolerances and stability, the RTD is usually preferable.
- Consider the environment. Intense vibration, thermal shock and aggressive atmospheres favor the thermocouple or a reinforced construction.
- Consider speed. A rapid temperature variation favors a low-mass thermocouple.
- Consider the cable run. A thermocouple requires extension cable of the proper type; an RTD requires three or four wires to compensate for resistance.
- Consider maintenance. Thermocouple drift may require more frequent replacements or checks.
An example
For a moderate-temperature process with tight control and stability, such as a bath or a heat exchanger, the RTD is a natural option. For a very high-temperature furnace, or one with vibration, the thermocouple is the reasonable alternative.
How to interpret the result
When both cover the range, the decision comes down to the required accuracy versus ruggedness and speed. They can be combined: an RTD as a reference and thermocouples for operation.