Approach: measurement is part of the process
In production, a bad measurement produces bad decisions: good product is rejected or defective product is accepted. That is why the measurement system is treated as one more process, with requirements, verification and control.
Main steps
- Identify critical characteristics. Which dimensions, temperatures, pressures or other quantities determine that the product complies.
- Relate tolerance and uncertainty. The uncertainty of the measurement system must be a small fraction of the tolerance of the characteristic. If it is comparable, part of the observed variation is measurement noise.
- Evaluate the measurement system. Repeatability and reproducibility studies separate the variation contributed by the instrument and the operators from the real process variation.
- Maintain working and reference standards. In the plant, working standards calibrated against higher-level standards are used, and they are kept from being used as everyday tools.
- Verify between calibrations. Start-of-shift checks with a control part or check standard detect deviations before the next formal cycle.
- Control the environment. Temperature, vibration, cleanliness and air supply have an influence, above all on dimensional and high-resolution measurements.
- Define the reaction. What is done with the product if a verification fails: containment, reinspection and lot review.
What an engineer sees on the floor
Common sights include operators who get different results with the same part, instruments that “wander” when the shift or the temperature changes, and product accepted in the plant but rejected by the customer because of measurement differences. These signs usually point to insufficient measurement system capability, not to a process out of control.
When to review the measurement system
- When the process capability index looks poor but the parts are acceptable on reinspection.
- When the instrument, operator or method changes.
- When the product tolerance is tightened.
If the process reaches high capability, the limit may lie in the measurement, not in the manufacturing.