Two solutions to different problems
Both are directional, but they achieve directivity in different ways. A patch antenna is a flat conductor on a dielectric substrate with a ground plane underneath. A Yagi-Uda has a driven element, a reflector behind it and several directors in front, all parallel along a boom.
How each one radiates
The patch behaves like a resonant cavity: energy radiates from the edges of the conductor, and the resonance sets the frequency. Its beam is relatively wide and its gain modest. In a Yagi, the parasitic elements, being excited by the field of the active element, re-radiate with a phase that reinforces radiation forward and cancels it backward. Adding directors narrows the beam and raises the gain.
| Aspect | Patch | Yagi |
|---|---|---|
| Shape | Flat and low-profile | Long, with protruding elements |
| Gain | Moderate | Increases with the number of directors |
| Bandwidth | Narrow in simple designs | Narrow, and more so as gain rises |
| Polarization | Linear or circular depending on the feed | Linear, depending on orientation |
| Integration | Easy on printed circuit boards and on surfaces | Requires a mast and space |
Selection criteria
- If the antenna must be integrated into a product, panel or facade, the patch is the natural option.
- If range is needed on a fixed link and there is room for mounting, the Yagi offers higher gain.
- If circular polarization is required, the patch can be adapted with a suitable feed.
- If the environment includes wind or ice, the mechanical load of the Yagi should be considered.
What the engineer sees when measuring
In both cases, return loss is measured to see the usable bandwidth, and the pattern is measured to verify the pointing. The patch is very sensitive to the substrate and its immediate surroundings; the Yagi is sensitive to the accuracy of the lengths and spacings of its elements.