Two different ways of guiding a wave
Coaxial cable has two conductors and propagates a transverse electromagnetic (TEM) mode. That mode has no cutoff frequency, so coax works from DC upward. Its upper limit is set by the diameter: when the dimensions approach the wavelength, higher-order modes appear and the line stops being single-mode.
A waveguide is a hollow metal tube, usually rectangular, with a single conductor. It cannot propagate a TEM mode; it propagates TE or TM modes, each with a cutoff frequency below which the wave is attenuated instead of propagating. That is why it passes neither DC nor low frequencies.
Practical comparison
| Criterion | Coaxial | Waveguide |
|---|---|---|
| Band | Very wide, from DC upward | Limited by cutoff and by the onset of the next mode |
| Loss at microwave frequencies | Higher, due to the inner conductor and the dielectric | Lower, with no center conductor or solid dielectric |
| Power | Limited by the inner conductor and the dielectric | Higher, thanks to the large cross-section and air as the dielectric |
| Dispersion | Practically none in TEM | Present: group velocity depends on frequency |
| Size and flexibility | Compact, flexible | Bulky and rigid; dimensions grow as frequency falls |
| Connection to equipment | Standard connectors | Flanges and coaxial transitions |
What the engineer observes
In a sweep, a waveguide shows its cutoff as an abrupt drop in transmission at the low end of the band, and manufacturers define each size to work with margin between that cutoff and the higher-order mode. Outside that band, the measurement is not valid. Coax, by contrast, is measured over a continuous interval, although its loss increases with frequency, as does the effect of connector repeatability.
In measurements, each coax-to-waveguide transition adds a reflection and a loss that must be corrected in the calibration, so the reference plane must be brought up to the device.
When the comparison does not apply
If the system needs mobility, curved routes or several bands, coax is almost always the right choice. For a short high-power link or a millimeter-wave measurement where cable loss dominates, waveguide is the usual option. Many installations use both: coax in the laboratory and waveguide in the critical section.