24/7 emergencies 814 777 6921812 230 6079WhatsApp 811 786 0768
Electrónica MonterreyElectrónica MonterreyLaboratorios Creativeit Talk to an engineer
Menu

Spectrum Analyzer or Network Analyzer: What Does Each One Measure?

A spectrum analyzer measures which signals are present at its input and their amplitude at each frequency; a network analyzer measures how a device transforms a signal that the analyzer itself generates, with magnitude and phase.

The fundamental difference: receiver versus stimulus-response system

A spectrum analyzer is essentially a receiver. It sweeps or processes a frequency interval and displays the power of whatever reaches its input. It does not need to know where the signal comes from, which is why it works for unknown signals: carriers, harmonics, spurs, interference and noise.

A vector network analyzer (VNA) combines its own source with several receivers. It sends a test signal to the device under test and compares the incident wave with the reflected and transmitted waves. What it delivers are ratios, not absolute powers: S-parameters, with magnitude and phase.

What each one measures

Aspect Spectrum analyzer Network analyzer
Signal source None, except for an optional tracking generator Built-in and controlled
Typical result Amplitude versus frequency of the signals present S-parameters: reflection and transmission
Phase Not measured in a classic sweep Measured, with a coherent reference
Calibration Of the instrument’s level and frequency Vector error correction with standards, up to the device plane
Used for Emissions, spurs, occupied bandwidth, modulation Filters, antennas, cables, linear amplifiers

What the engineer sees on the screen

With a spectrum analyzer you see a trace with peaks: each peak is a signal and its height is its level. The noise floor and the resolution determine how small the visible signals can be. With a network analyzer you see the response of a device, for example the insertion loss of a filter or the return loss of an antenna, and that response is repeatable because the stimulus is known.

A spectrum analyzer with a tracking generator can measure the transmission of a device, but only as a scalar magnitude: there is no phase and no reflection measurement with vector correction. That is why its accuracy is lower than that of a VNA.

How to choose

  • If the question is what is on the air or on a cable, and how strong it is, use the spectrum analyzer.
  • If the question is how a component behaves, or how well matched it is, use the network analyzer.
  • If the device is nonlinear, such as an amplifier near compression, a classic VNA measures only its small-signal behavior; for the rest you need specific modes or a spectrum analyzer with calibrated sources.
We do real tests, on video! Watch them on our YouTube channel →

Do you have a problem nobody has been able to measure?

Talk directly to the engineer in charge, with no middlemen.

Talk to an engineer