The choice between these two materials cannot be settled by a single rule. It depends on the soil, the installation method and the service life required.
Solid copper
It is an excellent conductor and, in most soils, corrodes slowly. That stability is why it is used in horizontal conductors and long-life electrodes. Its drawbacks are cost and low hardness: a solid copper rod bends or deforms when driven into hard ground, so it usually requires pre-drilling.
Copper-clad steel
A steel core gives the rod the rigidity for driving, while a metallurgically bonded copper layer protects and conducts. It is more economical and makes it possible to reach depth. Its weak point is the cladding: if it is scratched, punctured or worn away in one area, the steel is exposed and a galvanic cell forms with the nearby copper, in which the steel acts as the anode and corrodes locally. The thickness of the cladding determines how much margin there is.
Selection criteria
- Soil aggressiveness: in soils with high levels of moisture, salts or acidity, solid copper has the advantage of not depending on a thin layer.
- Ground hardness: clad steel withstands driving better.
- Expected service life: the longer the required life, the more weight the cladding or the solid section carries.
- Neighboring materials: copper is more noble than steel, aluminum and zinc. Connecting it to buried steel structures promotes their corrosion.
- Risk of theft: solid copper is a more attractive target for theft than clad steel, depending on the site.
An example decision
For a vertical rod that has to be driven into compact ground, clad steel of suitable thickness is practical. For a horizontal conductor buried in aggressive soil, solid copper is safer in the long term.
Specific requirements must be taken from the standard and project in force, and installation is the responsibility of qualified personnel.