Both methods measure ground resistance, but they answer different questions. The main difference lies in which part of the circuit they include in the result.
Stakes: fall of potential
Two auxiliary probes are driven into the ground, current is injected between the electrode under test and one of them, and the voltage is measured against the other. The result corresponds to the electrode (or grid) relative to remote earth, which is what matters for calculating ground potential rises and touch voltages.
- Advantages: absolute value, verifiable with the plateau curve, applicable to a single electrode.
- Limitations: it needs open space and ground into which probes can be driven, time to place them and, in the classic method, normally disconnecting the electrode.
Clamp: closed loop
The clamp measures the resistance of a loop formed by the electrode, the soil and the other return paths. It requires neither probes nor disconnection.
- Advantages: speed, no leads to lay out, useful in urban or paved areas where stakes cannot be driven.
- Limitations: it needs a closed loop; the result includes the rest of the loop; an isolated electrode cannot be measured; it does not reveal a broken section if another metallic path exists.
How to choose
- If the electrode is the only one or an acceptance or design value is needed, use stakes.
- If there are many electrodes in parallel with a common neutral and the aim is to detect changes or trends, the clamp is practical.
- If there is no room for the probes, consider selective clamp measurement, which combines probes with measurement of the current through the electrode.
A criterion for combining them
Many installations use both: a reference value with stakes at commissioning or after a modification, and periodic clamp checks compared against that reference. If the clamp shows a change, it is confirmed with stakes.
When the clamp does not apply
On a single electrode of a substation or of a lightning rod system with no return path, a clamp reading is meaningless. The methods must be applied in accordance with the standard in force and by qualified personnel, under safety regulations.