24/7 emergencies 814 777 6921812 230 6079WhatsApp 811 786 0768
Electrónica MonterreyElectrónica MonterreyLaboratorios Creativeit Talk to an engineer
Menu

Vertical rod or horizontal electrode?

It depends on how soil resistivity changes with depth: the vertical rod wins when the deep layers conduct better, and the horizontal electrode wins when the surface layer does.

The right question

The resistance of a grounding system depends on the geometry of the electrode and on the resistivity of the soil in which it is buried. Before choosing the electrode, you need to know how the soil behaves with depth. A layered resistivity study answers that better than any general rule.

When the vertical rod is the better choice

  • The surface soil is dry, sandy or stony, and further down there is stable moisture or better soil.
  • Space is limited and a long conductor cannot be laid out.
  • Less seasonal variation is sought, because deep layers dry out and freeze less than the surface.

Lengthening a rod reduces the resistance appreciably, while increasing its diameter has a much smaller effect.

When the horizontal electrode is the better choice

  • Beneath a thin layer of soil there is rock or highly resistive material, and a rod cannot be driven deep.
  • The surface layer is the best conductor.
  • There is room to lay a long conductor or a grid, which also controls potential gradients at the surface.

What is seen in the field

A typical case: a rod is driven and the measurement comes out high. A resistivity profile reveals that the soil improves considerably at greater depth, and a longer rod or a second, well-spaced rod solves the problem. In another case, rock at shallow depth prevents driving, and a conductor buried in a trench along a moist stretch works better.

Combining both is the norm

Real systems usually mix the two: a horizontal grid or ring with rods at key points. Several rods in parallel do not add up like independent resistors if they are very close together, because their zones of influence overlap; spacing them a distance comparable to their length makes better use of them.

Common mistakes

  • Choosing out of habit without measuring soil resistivity.
  • Measuring resistance in the wet season and assuming it will hold in the dry season.
  • Placing rods too close to each other.
  • Thinking a low resistance is enough: joint continuity and step and touch potentials also matter.
  • Forgetting the corrosion of buried material and connections.

Design and measurement in energized electrical installations are the responsibility of qualified personnel following the applicable regulations.

We do real tests, on video! Watch them on our YouTube channel →

Do you have a problem nobody has been able to measure?

Talk directly to the engineer in charge, with no middlemen.

Talk to an engineer