Two different questions
The pass/fail, or withstand, test answers whether the insulation holds a defined voltage for a set time without breakdown. The answer is yes or no. The diagnostic test answers what condition the insulation is in: it measures quantities such as resistance, polarization index, dissipation factor or partial discharge, and interprets them as condition indicators.
Pass/fail
- Advantage: the result is clear and easy to document, ideal for acceptance of new equipment or after a repair.
- Limitation: equipment that passes may be deteriorated and fail shortly afterward; with equipment that fails, the chance to learn why is lost, because the breakdown destroys the evidence.
- Stress: it subjects the insulation to a high voltage, which consumes service life in aged insulation.
Diagnostic
- Advantage: it allows comparison with previous values, with similar equipment and with other phases, and makes it possible to anticipate problems.
- Limitation: interpretation demands judgment and experience, and there is no universal limit value; it depends on the type of equipment, age and conditions.
- Stress: normally moderate, sometimes up to the service voltage or below it.
An example
On a cable being placed in service for the first time, a withstand test can be applied to verify the installation of joints and terminations. On the same cable, years later, dissipation factor and partial discharge measurements are made to decide whether it will stay in operation or its replacement should be planned.
How to combine them
A common scheme uses diagnostics to decide whether it is safe to apply a withstand test, and the withstand test to confirm the level. If the diagnostics show clearly degraded insulation, applying a high-voltage test may be unnecessary and harmful.
These activities involve hazardous voltages: they must be carried out by qualified, authorized personnel, following the applicable regulations and the facility’s lockout and grounding procedures.