What changes at the neutral
In a solidly grounded system, the neutral of the source is connected to ground without any intentional impedance. In a resistance grounded system, a resistor is inserted between neutral and ground. Everything else follows from that decision: the magnitude of the current when a phase touches ground.
Solid grounding
The ground-fault current is limited only by the impedance of the source and the fault path, so it can be comparable to that of a short circuit. This makes detection easier: overcurrent devices operate quickly and selectively. In exchange, the energy released at the fault point is large, with more equipment damage and higher arc energy. The voltage on the healthy phases barely rises, and the system can supply phase-to-neutral loads.
Resistance grounding
The resistor sets a ceiling on the ground-fault current. There are two philosophies:
- Low resistance: allows enough current for the protection to trip selectively, but much less than in a solid system. It reduces damage, but the fault is cleared.
- High resistance: limits the current to a value so small that the first fault causes no significant damage. An alarm is raised and the fault point is located without stopping the process.
Practical consequences
With high resistance, a second ground fault on another phase becomes a phase-to-phase short circuit, so the first fault must be located and corrected. In addition, the healthy phases are subjected to a higher voltage to ground during the fault, so the insulation and surge arresters must be compatible. These schemes are not used to supply loads connected to neutral without an additional transformer.
What is seen in the field: in resistance grounded systems, ground-fault protection by measuring residual current or the current in the resistor is essential; in solid systems, ground faults are cleared by conventional overcurrent protection.
How to decide
- If the process cannot tolerate a shutdown on a first ground fault, high resistance is an option.
- If there are single-phase loads to neutral and clearing the fault is the priority, the solid scheme is the usual one.
- If arc damage to power equipment is a concern, limiting with resistance helps.
The selection and design of the grounding system are defined by an engineering study in accordance with current regulations, and work on these systems is for qualified personnel.