Objective
Coordination seeks to clear a fault by disconnecting only the minimum necessary part of the installation. The device immediately upstream of the fault must operate first, and the others must remain closed or act as backup if the first one fails. This limits damage, maintains service in the rest of the plant, and makes the fault easy to locate.
How it is achieved
Each device has a time-current characteristic: the higher the current, the shorter the operating time. The curves of the devices in series, from the load to the source, are overlaid on the same current scale. For coordination to exist, the curve of the downstream device must lie to the left of the upstream device’s curve, with a time margin that covers tolerances, opening time, and relay error.
The analysis is done over the range of possible currents, from overload up to the maximum short-circuit current at each point, so it depends on a prior short-circuit study.
What other limits are respected
- The damage curves of equipment: transformers, cables, and motors. The protection must act before the equipment is damaged.
- Normal starting and energizing currents, which must not cause trips.
- The interrupting capacity of each device against the available fault current.
The trade-off with arc energy
Delaying an upstream device to achieve coordination increases the time a fault remains fed, and with it the energy released in an electric arc. A balance is sought, with functions such as zone selectivity or maintenance modes that shorten the clearing time during interventions.
What is seen in practice
A poorly coordinated installation shows main breaker trips for a fault on a branch, or shutdowns of an entire plant for a local problem. Coordination is verified by testing relays and trip units, because the setting on paper is not enough if the device does not respond according to its curve. Settings and tests are carried out by qualified personnel in accordance with the applicable regulations.