Two ways of acting
A passive filter uses inductances and capacitors tuned to one or more harmonic frequencies. It offers those harmonics a low-impedance path and diverts them from the grid. An active filter measures the load current in real time, separates its harmonic component and uses a converter to generate an equal and opposite current, so that the grid sees only the fundamental part.
Passive filter
- For: it is robust, simple in construction and low in cost at high power. It supplies capacitive reactive power, useful if compensation is needed.
- Against: it acts only near its tuned frequencies and its performance depends on the grid impedance. It can create parallel resonances with the grid. It can also absorb harmonics from other loads and become overloaded. Its tuning shifts as the components age.
Active filter
- For: it responds across a wide range of harmonics, adapts to load changes, depends less on grid impedance and does not create resonances. Depending on the model, it can also compensate reactive power or unbalance.
- Against: it has a compensation current limit; if the distortion exceeds its capacity, whatever it cannot cancel stays on the grid. It is more complex, with power electronics that generate losses and require maintenance, and it usually costs more per unit of compensated current.
How to choose
- Measure the current spectrum and how it varies over time. If it is stable and concentrated in a few orders, the passive filter is a candidate; if it is variable or broad-spectrum, the active filter.
- Evaluate the grid impedance and the risk of resonance.
- Decide whether compensating reactive power or unbalance is also of interest.
- Consider a hybrid arrangement: passive for the dominant harmonics and active for the rest.
Common mistakes
- Choosing by initial cost without measuring the spectrum.
- Installing a passive filter without studying resonance with the grid.
- Sizing the active filter with the rated load current instead of the actual harmonic current.
Installation must be done by qualified personnel, in accordance with applicable electrical regulations.