What changes between the two
A fixed bank stays connected as long as the installation is energized and supplies constant reactive power. An automatic bank is divided into steps, and a controller measures the power factor or the reactive power at the service entrance and switches steps in or out with contactors or thyristors to approach the target.
When fixed correction is enough
- Loads that operate steadily, with almost constant reactive demand.
- Correction of a transformer’s magnetizing current, which does not depend on the load.
- Individual correction of a motor that always runs close to its typical load, connected with its starter.
It is simple and low-maintenance, but if the load drops, the reactive power supplied becomes excessive: the system is overcompensated, the current becomes capacitive and the voltage can rise. In individually corrected motors, an oversized capacitor can cause overvoltage when the motor is disconnected while still turning.
When automatic correction is the better choice
When the load varies with shifts, processes or seasons. The controller follows the demand and avoids overcompensation. In exchange, it requires setting the controller properly (target, sensitivity, time between switching operations), placing the measuring current transformer at the correct point, where it sees the load and not the bank, and respecting the discharge time of the steps before reconnecting them.
Points that apply to both
- Check harmonics before installing, because capacitors can resonate with the grid.
- Select the capacitor for the actual voltage and harmonic content.
- Protect with suitable fuses or circuit breakers and provide safe discharge.
How to decide
A load profile recorded over a representative period shows how much reactive power is constant (the fixed part) and how much varies (the automatic part). Many installations use a combination: a fixed base and automatic steps for the rest. Installation and maintenance of capacitor banks are work for qualified personnel.