The question decides
Neither one is better than the other. They differ in the kind of question they answer. The portable answers “what is happening to this installation now?”; the fixed meter answers “how does this point behave over time?”.
When the portable is the right choice
- There is a symptom (stoppages, heating, trips) and the origin is unknown.
- Measurements are needed at different points in succession to locate a source.
- A condition is being evaluated before and after a change, such as installing a capacitor bank or a filter.
- The measurement is periodic or seasonal and does not justify an instrument installed at each point.
Its advantage is flexibility. Its limits are that it only sees the period during which it is connected and that each connection involves work in panels, with the risk that entails.
When the fixed meter is the right choice
- Continuous monitoring is required at a service entrance or in a critical process.
- A long history must be kept to detect trends, degradation or sporadic events.
- The data are integrated into a supervisory system with alarms.
- There is an obligation to demonstrate compliance on an ongoing basis.
Its advantage is that it is always there when the rare event occurs. Its limits are the installation investment, lower flexibility and the dependence on the measurement point having been chosen well.
How to decide
- Define whether the problem is one-off or recurring.
- Decide how many points and for how long.
- Evaluate access and the cost of connecting in energized panels.
- Assess whether the data must be integrated into other systems.
A common arrangement
It is usual to combine them: a fixed meter at the service entrance for permanent tracking and a portable to investigate a feeder when the fixed meter detects something. In both cases the instrument must have the accuracy, sensors and measurement class the use demands. Installation must be done by qualified personnel.