The essential difference
Both supply breathable air independent of the surrounding atmosphere. The difference is where the air is. With self-contained apparatus (SCBA), it is in a cylinder the person carries on their back. With an airline respirator, it is outside, in a compressor or cylinders, and arrives through a hose.
Comparison
| Aspect | Airline | Self-contained |
|---|---|---|
| Duration | As long as there is supply | Limited by the cylinder and exertion |
| Mobility | Limited by the hose | Free, no tethers |
| Weight on the person | Low | Higher, due to the cylinder |
| Access through small openings | Easier | Harder because of the cylinder’s bulk |
| Inherent risk | Tangled or cut hose; source failure | Running out of air; fatigue |
| Infrastructure | Source, filters, CO monitor, hoses | Charged cylinders and inspection |
How to decide
Duration of the work
For long tasks in one place, the airline avoids having to leave to change cylinders. For brief or reconnaissance tasks, self-contained apparatus is practical.
Distance and geometry
A long hose along a route with many turns gets snagged. If the person has to move around a lot, self-contained apparatus offers freedom, at the cost of its limited time.
Atmospheric hazard
When a supply failure would immediately endanger life, the airline must carry an escape reserve, or self-contained apparatus is used. For rescue, which involves entering an unknown atmosphere, positive-pressure self-contained apparatus or an airline combined with an escape bottle is preferred.
Support capability
An airline requires a reliable source, air quality monitoring and someone to watch over it. If this cannot be guaranteed, it is not an option.
Combination as a solution
Many systems combine an airline with a small escape cylinder: the person works with unlimited air and, if the line fails, switches to the cylinder to get out.
What both require
Training, medical fitness, mask fit, inspection and maintenance, and an exit plan. Selection is the responsibility of trained personnel, in accordance with the applicable regulations.
This guide is for information only. Work involving electrical hazards, heights or hazardous atmospheres must be performed by qualified and authorized personnel, following the applicable regulations.