Short answer
No antenna creates energy: it only distributes it. An omnidirectional antenna radiates uniformly in the horizontal plane, and a directional antenna concentrates that same energy into a narrower beam. That is why the directional antenna has more gain in its pointing direction and less in the others.
What changes in the pattern
The pattern of an ideal omnidirectional antenna is toroidal: uniform in azimuth, with a null upward and downward. To increase its gain, the vertical pattern is narrowed, not the horizontal one. A directional antenna also narrows the beam in the horizontal plane, so it must be aimed carefully.
| Criterion | Omnidirectional | Directional |
|---|---|---|
| Coverage | The entire horizontal plane | A limited sector |
| Gain | Lower | Higher on its axis |
| Aiming | Not required | Critical |
| Interference rejection | Low | High outside the beam |
| Typical use | One point serving many clients | Point-to-point links |
How to decide
- Count the stations at the other end. If there is only one in a fixed position, a directional antenna offers more range and less interference.
- If the units are scattered or moving, an omnidirectional antenna avoids having to reorient.
- Evaluate the interference environment: the directional antenna rejects sources located outside its beam.
- Consider the vertical geometry. If there is a large height difference, a very narrow vertical pattern can leave out the far end.
What the engineer sees when measuring
A horizontal pattern cut shows a nearly uniform circle for the omnidirectional antenna and a main lobe with side lobes for the directional antenna. A real omnidirectional antenna is never perfectly uniform, because the mast and nearby objects introduce ripple.
When the comparison does not apply
If the required coverage is a sector, for example 120 degrees, neither the omnidirectional antenna nor the narrow directional antenna is ideal; sector antennas with a wide horizontal beam exist for that case.